Beauty Boxes Made Me Buy It

Either by trying similar things repeatedly or finding a cheaper alternative to a product I’ve tried, these are things I wouldn’t be using now if I hadn’t tried them in a subscription first.

Beauty Box Battle: May 2018 + April 2018 Update

One of my boxes bored me so badly that led me to cut off my subscription right before it renewed. Can you guess which one got the ax and what I’m replacing it with?